CMBS Loan Modifications With Paydowns Fare Twice as Well

Only one in five CMBS modifications included a paydown, yet those loans were half as likely to be in trouble a year later, per Trepp.
3 min read
CMBS Loan Modifications With Paydowns Fare Twice as Well
  • Of 966 CMBS modifications since January 2022, 210 included a paydown of at least 1% of the balance, totaling $2.0 billion, with a typical paydown of 5.4%.
  • Twelve months out, 21% of paydown loans were in special servicing, delinquent or liquidated versus 40% of those without one, and the gap held at 24 months.
  • A paydown looks like the strongest signal of a committed borrower, while higher reserves did not track with better outcomes, which matters for servicers weighing extensions.
Key Takeaways

Borrowers who wrote a check as part of a CMBS loan modification were roughly half as likely to end up in trouble later, a Trepp analysis finds.

Few do. Of 966 modified loans since early 2022, only about 1 in 5 included a paydown.

Who Pays and How Much

Paydowns of at least 1% of balance showed up on 210 deals, totaling $2.0B. The typical one was 5.4%, though the top decile topped 18%. Borrowers funded nearly all of it, and only 23 were funded by selling off one property from a portfolio loan.

Special servicers pressed for them more often than master servicers, on 28% of deals versus 10%. Larger loans paid more, with single-asset deals at 32% against 19% for conduit loans, and loans over $100M at 27%.

Property type mattered too. Mixed use topped the list at 31%, ahead of multifamily (27%) and office (24%), while hotels sat at 15% and industrial at 12%.

Figure 1: Share of Modifications with a Paydown, 2022 to October 2026

What a Paydown Buys

Extensions carry most of them: 31% included one, compared with 2% of forbearance deals. Payers still got no extra time, because both groups typically received 12 months.

A 2023 New York office workout shows the full package. The servicer gave roughly two more years in exchange for a $5M paydown and over $6M deposited into leasing and capital reserves.

Does It Help?

The firm tracked two years of special servicer modifications. After 12 months, 21% of paydown loans remained with the special servicer, were delinquent or had been liquidated, against 40% of loans without a paydown. By month 24 the split was 17% to 39%, and about half of payers (51%) had paid off versus 18%.

Payers started with stronger credit: a typical debt service coverage ratio of 1.69x versus 1.44x, and loan-to-value of 54% versus 59%. The edge held inside every coverage and leverage band, though. For borrowers with matching coverage and property type, 21% of payers struggled within a year, compared with 36% of non-payers.

Reserves Tell a Murkier Story

Reserves rose on 27% of modifications, adding $1.13B, typically 2.8% of the balance. Just 6% paired higher reserves with a paydown.

Loans with higher reserves fared worse than the rest, with 29% in trouble within a year versus 24%. Trepp says some of those reserves are just excess cash trapped and swept from the property, not new money from borrowers.

Why It Matters

Modified debt is now a big slice of the market. Our earlier look at CMBS modifications found servicers have reworked $98.3B since 2022, with a little over 21% of the remaining balance delinquent versus 4.7% for loans never modified.

Servicers are also running out of easy exits. Trepp’s data, covered in our report on failed workouts, showed foreclosure at 23% of special servicing exits while modifications fell to 37% from 54% in 2024.

What’s Next

Trepp calls paydowns the exception but the strongest signal in its data. Watch whether servicers lean harder on borrowers for cash as extensions get tougher to justify.

Related To

CRE Daily - No Cap

podcast

No CAP by CRE Daily

No Cap by CRE Daily is a weekly podcast offering an unfiltered look into commercial real estate’s biggest trends and influential figures.

CRE Daily Newsletters

Join 65k+
  • operators
  • developers
  • brokers
  • owners
  • landlords
  • investors
  • lenders

who start their day with CRE Daily.

The latest news and trends in commercial real estate delivered to your inbox. Get smarter about what matters in just 5-minutes or less.