CMBS Modifications Top $98B, but 21% Are Delinquent Again

Servicers have modified 966 CMBS loans since 2022, yet more than one in five dollars still outstanding from those deals has gone delinquent.
3 min read
CMBS Modifications Top $98B, but 21% Are Delinquent Again
  • Servicers have modified 966 CMBS loans with $98.3 billion of balance since January 2022, and 21.3% of the $49.8 billion still outstanding is delinquent.
  • Most deals only buy time: 61% extended the maturity, typically by 12 months, while just 22% required a paydown and 27% raised reserves.
  • Delinquency on modified loans runs more than four times the 4.7% rate for loans never modified, with mixed use the worst major type at 43%.
Key Takeaways

Since 2022, servicers have reworked $98.3 billion of CMBS loans, and about one in five dollars left on those deals has slid back into delinquency, according to Trepp.

About $49.8 billion of that balance remains. A little over 21% of it is delinquent, versus 4.7% for loans never modified.

A Growing Pile of Modified Debt

Trepp tallies 966 modified loans since January 2022. The peak came in 2025, when servicers reworked 281 loans carrying $28.4 billion. So far in 2026, the count is 141 loans and $17.4 billion through October.

Late reporting will push that 2026 figure up, but the year is still tracking behind 2025. Earlier years ran from $12.7 billion in 2022 to $18.2 billion in 2023 and $21.6 billion in 2024.

Their weight has grown fast: 7.3% of the CMBS market today, up from just 1.3% when 2022 ended.

chart of CMBS Loan Modifications by Year, 2022 to 2026

Time, Not Money

Servicers mostly bought borrowers time. About 61% of deals pushed out the maturity, usually by a year, and 24% were forbearance agreements.

New money was scarcer. Only 22% of modifications came with a paydown, typically around 5% of the balance, while 27% raised reserves and 10% added a cash trap. By Trepp’s math, at most 49% demanded either, and in some cases the reserves were funded from property cash flow, not fresh borrower equity.

chart showing new modifications are replacing the covid wave

Office Takes Over the Queue

Since 2022, office accounts for 36% of the modified balance, with retail at 21%. Lodging topped the list in 2022 at 31% and has shrunk to 8% this year.

These are not healthy loans. Half had fallen behind on payments sometime in the half-year ahead of the deal.

Modified, Not Fixed

Outside office, the gap is stark. Retail loans that were modified are 24% delinquent, against 2% for retail never touched. Lodging runs 26% versus 1%.

Office looks shaky regardless, at 19% versus 10%. Mixed use fares worst among the big categories at 43%.

Loans still carrying a pandemic-era modification look worse yet. Close to a third of that balance is delinquent, and 47% sits with a special servicer.

chart showing that modified does not mean fixed

Zoom Out

An earlier Trepp study of how loans exit special servicing, which we covered, found modifications shrinking to 37% of resolved balance in 2026 from 54% in 2024, while foreclosures climbed to 23%.

This follow-up shows why servicers are backing away. The loans they did rework are slipping back at a high rate.

Why It Matters

Trepp points to one 2023 office deal as typical: roughly two more years for the borrower, for $500,000 down and $1 million in leasing reserves.

Terms depend on who handles the loan. Paydowns showed up in 28% of special servicer deals but only 10% of master servicer ones, and reserve increases in 36% versus 12%.

Master servicers now handle 48% of modifications, up from 34% in earlier years. That sits against a special servicing rate of 11.74%, a 13-year high, we covered earlier this month.

What’s Next

Special servicer deals often post late, so the gap between servicer types may narrow with more data. Trepp’s takeaway is blunt: extra time alone does not guarantee a lasting fix.

Related To

CRE Daily - No Cap

podcast

No CAP by CRE Daily

No Cap by CRE Daily is a weekly podcast offering an unfiltered look into commercial real estate’s biggest trends and influential figures.

CRE Daily Newsletters

Join 65k+
  • operators
  • developers
  • brokers
  • owners
  • landlords
  • investors
  • lenders

who start their day with CRE Daily.

The latest news and trends in commercial real estate delivered to your inbox. Get smarter about what matters in just 5-minutes or less.