Apartment Reappraisals Cut Values 33% on Distressed Loans

New appraisals on 295 securitized apartment loans slashed property values 33% to $6.5 billion, leaving 57% of the loans underwater.
3 min read
Apartment Reappraisals Cut Values 33% on Distressed Loans
  • CRED iQ found 295 securitized apartment loans reappraised in 2026 fell from $9.7 billion at securitization to $6.5 billion, a 33% drop, with a 44% median loss.
  • Most of these loans were already troubled: 92% were delinquent or in special servicing, and their median loan-to-value ratio rose from 63% to 101%.
  • The deepest cuts hit small New York buildings, where the median property lost 54%, while 2023 through 2026 vintages lost 39% in aggregate.
Key Takeaways

New appraisals on 295 securitized apartment loans this year show values down 33%, to $6.5 billion from $9.7 billion when the loans were packaged, according to CRED iQ.

More than half of them, 57%, now carry more debt than the property is worth. That adds up to $3.7 billion of loans.

Trouble Triggers the Appraisal

Appraisals tend to follow trouble. Nearly all of this group, 92%, was already late or in special servicing. Among the 272 distressed loans, the typical property shed 45% of its value and leverage jumped from 63% to 101% of value.

CRED iQ stresses this is a distressed slice of the market, not all apartments. The 23 loans still performing went the other way, gaining 24% at the median.

One Ohio property is the extreme case: Euclid Apartments. It was appraised at $77.0 million in 2024 against a $48.0 million loan, then at $18.1 million in April. A receiver appointed by the court now manages the building, which was about one-third occupied.

chart of 295 reappraised apartment loans dated january to october 2026

By Deal Type

Freddie Mac deals dominate the sample with 211 loans. Values there fell 33% and 62% of the loans are underwater. Conduit CMBS follows with 68 loans, down 32%, 38% underwater.

The 10 single-asset loans lost 35%, with 80% underwater. The six CRE CLO loans dropped 27%, with 67% underwater.

New York’s Small Buildings Took the Deepest Cuts

The New York metro supplies 130 loans, and the typical property there lost 54%. Most are small, around 22 units with a $4.6 million loan. Outside the metro, the typical loss was a third.

In New York, 105 loans came from Freddie Mac’s small-balance program, and 83 were packaged in 2019. Dallas-Fort Worth saw a typical 42% cut and Houston 35%, while Los Angeles stood alone among large metros with a rising median.

Floating-rate Freddie Mac loans from 2022 took big hits. One in Glendale, Ariz., dropped from $137.0 million to $62.5 million, and one in Grand Prairie, Texas, from $155.4 million to $82.9 million.

Big and New Loans Are Not Spared

Parkmerced in San Francisco now carries a $1.43 billion valuation, below its $1.46 billion in debt and far from the $2.11 billion appraisal of 2019. A $225 million Queens loan was marked at $178.6 million, versus $322.5 million in 2021.

Newer loans fared no better. The 45 from 2023 through 2026 deals lost 39% in aggregate. A Michigan conduit property once valued at $73.0 million now carries a $19.4 million appraisal, under its $28.8 million loan.

Zoom Out

Office has seen the same math. We covered how the 26 Broadway appraisal fell 68% to $147 million after the loan went to special servicing.

Apartments are following a similar path, from a lower starting point of stress.

Why It Matters

CRED iQ argues that delinquency shows which loans are in trouble and appraisals show what remains. The 44% median loss exceeds the equity cushion these loans began with, at 63% leverage.

That shapes workouts. When Brookfield handed back the Beaudry in Los Angeles, CMBS apartment delinquency had already hit 8%.

What’s Next

With $3.7 billion of debt sitting above appraised value, CRED iQ says any workout now begins from the new valuation, not the figure in the offering documents. October data is preliminary.

CRE Daily - No Cap

podcast

No CAP by CRE Daily

No Cap by CRE Daily is a weekly podcast offering an unfiltered look into commercial real estate’s biggest trends and influential figures.

CRE Daily Newsletters

Join 65k+
  • operators
  • developers
  • brokers
  • owners
  • landlords
  • investors
  • lenders

who start their day with CRE Daily.

The latest news and trends in commercial real estate delivered to your inbox. Get smarter about what matters in just 5-minutes or less.