Build-to-Rent Firms Fight Treasury Rules Ahead of a Shakeout

Build-to-rent operators are pressing Treasury to soften proposed investor rules, yet a wave of mergers looks likely whatever the agency decides.
2 min read
Build-to-Rent Firms Fight Treasury Rules Ahead of a Shakeout
  • Bisnow reported that proposed Treasury rules would require investors with 350 or more rental homes to adopt written BTR programs before buying and bar purchases more than 18 months after certificate of occupancy.
  • More than 100 public comments are in, and the comment period closes Nov. 23. Operators say the rules could hurt homebuilders’ ability to sell excess inventory to BTR buyers.
  • Bisnow reports compliance costs, aging debt and fund lifecycles are squeezing smaller operators, while Invitation Homes and American Homes 4 Rent look like natural consolidators.
Key Takeaways

Consolidation is coming for single-family rental whatever Treasury decides, and build-to-rent operators are pushing to keep the rules from choking new supply, according to Bisnow.

Bisnow reported that the pressure follows a summer lobbying fight over the housing law that restricts large investors.

What Treasury Proposed

Per Bisnow, the draft rules cover big institutional owners, meaning anyone holding 350 or more single-family rentals. They’d need written BTR programs before buying a community, and couldn’t buy a home once 18 months have passed since its certificate of occupancy.

Quinn Residences CEO Richard Ross told Bisnow a new community often needs about two years or longer to stabilize, and that the rules would make it tougher for homebuilders to unload surplus houses on BTR buyers.

Industry Pushback

Bisnow said more than 100 comments have been filed so far and the window closes Nov. 23. Ross, whose firm owns or built 5,200 homes in 34 communities, told Bisnow that capital flows would take a serious hit if the rules stand.

National Rental Home Council CEO Adrianne Todman told Bisnow Treasury’s rules are thoughtful but that BTR units should be clearly exempt. She said capital that froze during the legislative fight is thawing.

Why Consolidation Looms

Mizuho analyst Haendel St. Juste told Bisnow compliance costs hit smaller firms hardest, just as private equity funds age and loans made roughly five to seven years back reach the end of their lives.

Bisnow noted VineBrook Homes Trust suspended buybacks and flagged a $650.8 million maturity within a year.

Zoom Out

The law’s design shapes who wins. Bloomberg reported it bars institutions with 350 or more homes from buying existing houses but leaves built-to-rent paths open. Invitation Homes’ Scott Eisen said on the No Cap podcast that institutions own only about 3% of U.S. single-family rentals.

Why It Matters

Bisnow reported the two largest listed single-family landlords, Invitation Homes and its rival American Homes 4 Rent, trade at deep discounts to net asset value and are selling homes to fund buybacks. Invitation sold 658 homes in Q3, and Land & Buildings wants at least $2 billion a year returned to shareholders.

Mizuho sees the legislation as a sizable rollup opportunity for the two REITs.

What’s Next

Bisnow said new senators-elect who campaigned against corporate home ownership could add pressure. After the Nov. 23 deadline, the final rules will show how much BTR gets carved out.

CRE Daily - No Cap

podcast

No CAP by CRE Daily

No Cap by CRE Daily is a weekly podcast offering an unfiltered look into commercial real estate’s biggest trends and influential figures.

CRE Daily Newsletters

Join 65k+
  • operators
  • developers
  • brokers
  • owners
  • landlords
  • investors
  • lenders

who start their day with CRE Daily.

The latest news and trends in commercial real estate delivered to your inbox. Get smarter about what matters in just 5-minutes or less.