26 Broadway Appraisal Falls 68% to $147M After Default

A new appraisal puts the Chetrits’ 26 Broadway at $147 million, down 68% in five years, with its $290 million loan in special servicing.
2 min read
26 Broadway Appraisal Falls 68% to $147M After Default
  • Morningstar Credit’s latest appraisal values 26 Broadway, the Financial District’s Standard Oil Building, at $147 million, 68% below a $465 million figure from five years ago.
  • The $290 million CMBS loan moved to special servicing in June. Cash flow is down about 30% from underwriting and debt service coverage sits at 0.76x, below breakeven.
  • Occupancy slid from 83% to 75% and the Chetrit family faces a $132 million judgment plus lender disputes, so the building is a test for its wider portfolio.
Key Takeaways

A fresh appraisal values 26 Broadway at $147 million, down 68% from $465 million about five years ago, The Real Deal reports, citing Morningstar Credit (the figure was first reported by Bisnow).

The mark follows a June move of the building’s $290 million CMBS loan to special servicing.

How the Loan Slid

Starwood Mortgage Capital and Bank of Montreal made the loan in 2022. The special servicer took it over once the Chetrits (Meyer and Jacob’s estate) acknowledged they would stop paying.

Per Morningstar’s June report, net cash flow had dropped roughly 30% since underwriting. Higher insurance, utility and maintenance bills pushed debt service coverage down to 0.76x.

Occupancy and Ownership

The Standard Oil Building, 29 floors and 840,000 square feet, was 83% occupied at underwriting in 2021. Morningstar put it at 75% at the close of Q1.

The family paid $225 million for the ground lease in 2007, and Meyer and Joseph added the land for $35 million in 2010. Their company later divided in two, with the Chetrit Organization owning this tower. Jacob signed the mortgages.

Zoom Out

The Chetrits’ Financial District troubles aren’t new. We covered MetroLoft’s purchase of 1 Whitehall Street, a building LoanCore took over after the Chetrit Organization defaulted on a $156 million loan.

A spokesperson for Meyer Chetrit and Jacob’s estate had no comment on the report.

Why It Matters

A markdown this steep shows how fast leveraged older office can lose value. Trepp’s special servicing rate hit 11.49% in the reading we covered, a level last seen in 2013, with office making up most new inflows.

Meyer Chetrit said in depositions this summer that the Chetrit Group has effectively dissolved and has no cash. He valued its portfolio at negative $80 million, a swing from roughly $1 billion in under four years.

What’s Next

The family also owes Maverick Real Estate Partners $132 million under a judgment, and it faces tenant harassment charges and lender disputes on other properties. With the value this low, the servicer’s next step on 26 Broadway will show how much of the loan it expects back.

CRE Daily - No Cap

podcast

No CAP by CRE Daily

No Cap by CRE Daily is a weekly podcast offering an unfiltered look into commercial real estate’s biggest trends and influential figures.

CRE Daily Newsletters

Join 65k+
  • operators
  • developers
  • brokers
  • owners
  • landlords
  • investors
  • lenders

who start their day with CRE Daily.

The latest news and trends in commercial real estate delivered to your inbox. Get smarter about what matters in just 5-minutes or less.