Menlo Park Fights 39-Story Tower Under Builder’s Remedy

A developer is invoking California’s Builder’s Remedy to build a 39-story, 665-home tower in Menlo Park, and the state is backing him.
2 min read
Menlo Park Fights 39-Story Tower Under Builder's Remedy
  • N17 Development wants to build Willow Park in Menlo Park, with 665 homes plus offices, a hotel and shops, and a tallest tower of 39 stories, or 458 feet.
  • Menlo Park’s height limit in the district is 35 to 40 feet. The developer sued in October seeking $6.65 million in fines, and California’s attorney general warned the city to approve.
  • The case could test the Builder’s Remedy, which lets projects bypass local zoning where a city lacks a state-approved housing plan, and shape how forcefully California can push approvals.
Key Takeaways

A Silicon Valley developer is using California’s Builder’s Remedy to fast-track a 39-story project in a leafy Menlo Park neighborhood, The Wall Street Journal reports.

The tallest tower of Willow Park would rise 458 feet. City rules cap buildings in that district at 35 to 40 feet.

The Project

Developer Oisin Heneghan’s N17 Development proposes 665 residences along with office space, a hotel and retail on a nearly 7-acre parcel near Meta’s headquarters and Stanford. Fifteen percent of the homes would be affordable, with a two-bedroom at $2,556 a month, per a city analysis.

Neighbors and local officials call the towers oversize. Heneghan says the backlash is Nimbyism that blocks the housing renters need.

How the Remedy Works

The Builder’s Remedy lets developers skip local zoning in cities whose housing plans the state hasn’t approved. Menlo Park says it blew a January 2023 deadline for its plan because of administrative holdups in Sacramento.

N17 applied under the provision that year. The city has declined to sign off, saying it wants environmental review, including its effect on a nearby creek that is habitat for steelhead and a threatened frog.

In July, the office of California Attorney General Rob Bonta cautioned the city to yield or face penalties. In October, N17 filed suit for the landowner, asking for $6.65 million in fines that would fund housing.

Palo Alto Councilman Pat Burt told the Journal a loss for Menlo Park would probably leave other cities bowing to these projects. Palo Alto has agreed to back Menlo Park in court. YIMBY Law’s Sonja Trauss countered that stronger enforcement is a consequence for stonewalling.

A Side Dispute

Rep. Sam Liccardo asked the Treasury Department in late September to review the project, citing the owner’s Russian ties. A lawyer for owner Vitaly Yusufov told the Journal he has no Kremlin ties and called the claims a smear.

Why It Matters

Bay Area housing is tight. Apartments.com data we covered put San Francisco rents up 12.4% from March to $3,644 with vacancy at 3.5%, and Bloomberg Businessweek’s analysis of AI wealth flagged housing strain as startup money pours in.

A ruling for N17 would sharpen the state’s leverage over cities. A ruling for Menlo Park would give others a template to resist.

What’s Next

The lawsuit is the next marker. Watch for whether the court takes up the missed-deadline argument and for any Treasury action on the ownership questions.

CRE Daily - No Cap

podcast

No CAP by CRE Daily

No Cap by CRE Daily is a weekly podcast offering an unfiltered look into commercial real estate’s biggest trends and influential figures.

CRE Daily Newsletters

Join 65k+
  • operators
  • developers
  • brokers
  • owners
  • landlords
  • investors
  • lenders

who start their day with CRE Daily.

The latest news and trends in commercial real estate delivered to your inbox. Get smarter about what matters in just 5-minutes or less.