Guest: Mark Fogel, President and CEO, ACRES Capital
Mark Fogel is president and CEO of ACRES Commercial Realty, a publicly traded mortgage REIT. He co-founded ACRES Capital in 2012 to lend to the middle market sponsors the big banks overlooked. Before that, he ran asset management at Arbor Realty Trust for nearly a decade, straight through the global financial crisis.
Fogel compares the CDO excesses of 2007 with today’s CLO market, which he calls as strong as it has ever been. He recounts how ACRES took on a stressed mortgage REIT portfolio in March 2020, and why he thinks rising rates will push banks and CMBS holders to let go of assets. He also explains how ACRES works out middle market loans by bringing in new sponsors.
Key Takeaways
Fogel says he left a 2004 meeting about Arbor’s first CDO convinced the structure would push lenders into deals they did not want. By 2007, he says, CDO collateral included construction and land loans that could not go into a CLO today.
“This CDO machine is going to force you to do deals that you don’t want to do because you have to keep feeding the machine.”
Mark Fogel, [13:16]
Floating-rate, liquid CLO bonds are drawing far more buyers, and Fogel calls CLO financing the best form of financing for a lender. ACRES loads a warehouse line only for three to six months, when it can project where the CLO market will be.
“Now, if you go to market, there’s 25 different investors looking at the AAA.”
Mark Fogel, [24:06]
In March 2020, ACRES stepped in at the request of a struggling mortgage REIT’s board. About $3 billion of assets sat behind warehouse lines and CLOs, and a $400 million standby fund calmed lenders so no margin calls came.
“I told those guys, we’re not going to lose more than $50 million on this portfolio. And lo and behold, here we are today and we’ve lost $3 million on the entire portfolio.”
Mark Fogel, [43:42]
Fogel says rate increases erased exit strategies on 2021 and 2022 bridge loans, just as rents fell and insurance and taxes rose. Many lenders are still carrying those assets, and he says the good ones need time, not a fire sale.
“Nobody expected that the Fed was going to raise interest rates, but they did and very quickly. And so what happens when interest rates rise? All of a sudden your exit strategy on a bridge loan is gone.”
Mark Fogel, [45:07]
Fogel expects lenders to capitulate as rates rise, and says ACRES plans to lend to the buyers of those assets at heavily discounted levels. Where a borrower cannot fix a property, he brings in a new sponsor to step into a modified loan.
“I think the shoe is going to drop. I think with the rising rates, there’s going to be a lot of capitulation in the market.”
Mark Fogel, [53:24]
