CRE Activity Index Falls 14% as Rate Fears Stall Deals

The CRE Activity Index fell 14% to 113.9 in October as listings, appraisals and due diligence all slipped on renewed rate worries.
2 min read
CRE Activity Index Falls 14% as Rate Fears Stall Deals
  • LightBox’s CRE Activity Index dropped 14% to 113.9 in October from 131.7 in September, with listings, appraisals and environmental due diligence all declining together for the first time since July.
  • Average daily listings fell 20% after a September surge, appraisal volume slid 11%, and the index dipped below its 12-month average for the first time this year.
  • Markets price roughly an 80% chance of a December Fed hike, so LightBox calls the slowdown more a rate problem than a demand problem, with deals still moving but timelines stretching.
Key Takeaways

LightBox’s monthly CRE Activity Index dropped 14% in October to 113.9 as sellers, lenders and buyers all hit pause.

September’s reading was 131.7, so October lands back at July’s level.

chart of the lightboc cre activity index: january 2025 to present

Three Signals All Point Down

Listings, appraisals and Phase I environmental assessments all slid in the same month for the first time in three months, if by different amounts. Strong listings had been holding the index up. In October that cushion disappeared.

Average daily listings fell 20% after jumping 24% in September. They remain 26% higher than a year ago, versus 32% a month earlier.

Appraisals Are the Weak Spot

Appraisals fell 11% in the month and sit 17% under last October, after a 13% drop in September. LightBox calls it the weakest input and the clearest signal that financing is slowing the path from listing to closing.

Phase I work was flat, off 1% month over month and level with a year ago. Since that work follows acquisitions, refinancings and distressed deals, LightBox reads it as evidence that the late-summer listings spike hasn’t yet turned into advancing transactions.

Rates Drive the Caution

The Fed held rates in October, but a hot inflation report followed. Futures put the odds of a quarter-point hike in December near 80%, with a 10% to 15% shot at a half-point move.

Lending forecasts are softening too. The Mortgage Bankers Association now sees 2027 commercial mortgage lending growing about 1%, down from roughly 8%, with multifamily at 2%. Our report on the CREFC Sentiment Index covered its 17.5% drop to a three-year low.

Why It Matters

LightBox says deals are still closing. Multifamily led activity in its Q3 tracker, industrial and retail kept drawing institutional buyers, office saw fresh interest alongside distress, and senior housing attracted capital on demographics and thin supply.

That makes for a selective recovery: buyers move when pricing and fundamentals match, with no broad rebound. Major brokerages are also dialing back near-term projections, as our coverage of brokerage forecast cuts showed.

What’s Next

LightBox expects a careful close to the year. Some owners will list before financing gets tougher, buyers will wait, and appraisals will stay soft. The 10-year Treasury is near 4.9% after peaking at 5.35%, and oil is under $100, yet wider risk premiums keep borrowers from capturing the benefit.

November’s numbers will show if the slide continues. Another hot CPI print could freeze activity, while a calmer 10-year and clearer Fed signals could release sidelined deals. LightBox calls this a rate problem more than a demand problem.

CRE Daily - No Cap

podcast

No CAP by CRE Daily

No Cap by CRE Daily is a weekly podcast offering an unfiltered look into commercial real estate’s biggest trends and influential figures.

CRE Daily Newsletters

Join 65k+
  • operators
  • developers
  • brokers
  • owners
  • landlords
  • investors
  • lenders

who start their day with CRE Daily.

The latest news and trends in commercial real estate delivered to your inbox. Get smarter about what matters in just 5-minutes or less.