Capstone Buys $95M Garden City Office Loan for $51M

Capstone Equities paid $51 million for a $95 million nonperforming loan on Long Island’s Garden City Plaza, with Maxim Capital financing $41 million.
2 min read
Capstone Buys $95M Garden City Office Loan for $51M
  • Capstone Equities paid $51 million for the $95 million nonperforming loan on Garden City Plaza, a 600,000-square-foot Long Island office complex previously held by Bank of America.
  • Maxim Capital supplied $41 million in note-on-note financing, the sale was cooperative with owner Treeline Properties, and the deal closed in two weeks.
  • Discounted note purchases give banks a fast exit from troubled office debt, and Capstone has now bought two Garden City-area notes in a short span.
Key Takeaways

Capstone Equities founder Josh Zamir bought the nonperforming loan secured by Garden City Plaza, a Long Island office complex of 600,000 square feet, Commercial Observer reported.

He paid $51 million for a $95 million note, or about 54 cents on the dollar. Bank of America previously held the loan.

How the Deal Works

Maxim Capital put up $41 million of the money through note-on-note financing. The Nassau County complex is owned by Treeline Properties and covers four addresses, 100 to 400 Garden City Plaza.

Treeline stays in the deal, since the seller and borrower worked together on the sale. Zamir told Commercial Observer the whole process, due diligence included, took two weeks.

The Friendly Buyer Pitch

Zamir described Capstone as a borrower-friendly loan buyer: it buys at a discount, then works with the borrower on a solution or a tax-advantageous strategy. He told Commercial Observer that speed also helps banks, which can exit a position and close quickly.

Maxim’s Jason Bordenick, a portfolio manager and partner, pointed to Maxim’s familiarity with Long Island offices and its long relationship with Capstone. He told Commercial Observer the firm has become a go-to non-bank financing partner for investors buying distressed debt.

The Advisors and the Location

Iron Hound Management brokered the financing through Chris Herron and Jack Casper. On the buy side, Newmark advisors Adam Spies, Josh King and Brett Siegel represented Zamir.

The offices sit beside Simon Property Group’s Roosevelt Field Mall, ranked 11th among U.S. malls, and have easy transit access to Manhattan.

A Busy Stretch for Both Firms

This is Capstone’s 50th transaction and its second near Garden City. The firm also closed a $43 million Goldman Sachs refinancing on Franklin Plaza, a 488,835-square-foot Long Island office complex, last week, after earlier buying that property’s troubled note.

Maxim had its own recent activity: a $55 million loan in late October to recapitalize Juda Chetrit’s building at 1384 Broadway.

Why It Matters

Distressed office debt is moving, with CMBS special servicing at 11.49%, the highest since 2013, per our earlier coverage. Buyers who can close quickly and pay a discount are filling a gap for banks.

The 2027 debt wall adds to the pressure. We reported $733 billion of CRE debt comes due that year as extensions fade.

What’s Next

Capstone has now bought two Garden City-area notes in a short span. Watch whether Treeline and Capstone reach a restructuring or a sale at Garden City Plaza.

CRE Daily - No Cap

podcast

No CAP by CRE Daily

No Cap by CRE Daily is a weekly podcast offering an unfiltered look into commercial real estate’s biggest trends and influential figures.

CRE Daily Newsletters

Join 65k+
  • operators
  • developers
  • brokers
  • owners
  • landlords
  • investors
  • lenders

who start their day with CRE Daily.

The latest news and trends in commercial real estate delivered to your inbox. Get smarter about what matters in just 5-minutes or less.