- FS Credit REIT ended Q3 with $652.8M of loans on non-accrual, nearly triple year-end’s $219.5M, after a $358.8M multifamily loan stopped accruing interest in September.
- The roughly $3B nontraded REIT took back five apartment properties, saw net income fall to $30.3M from $59.8M, and posted negative returns across all seven share classes in September and October.
- Repurchase requests roughly doubled between July and September, yet the REIT filled all of them, showing how nontraded credit vehicles face credit and liquidity pressure at the same time.
FS Credit Real Estate Income Trust finished Q3 carrying $652.8M in non-accrual loans, almost triple the year-end figure, AltsWire reports.
A $358.8M multifamily loan that stopped accruing in September led the increase. The nontraded mortgage REIT, with roughly $3B of NAV, also foreclosed on five apartment properties in July and August.
Get Smarter about what matters in CRE
Stay ahead of trends in commercial real estate with CRE Daily – the free newsletter delivering everything you need to start your day in just 5-minutes
Risk Ratings Worsen
At Sept. 30, the REIT’s worst internal grade, a 5, covered five loans with $535.7M of amortized cost, about 6% of the portfolio. That grade signals probable loss or foreclosure.
Back in December, four loans worth $120.5M, 2% of the book, sat there. The next-worst grade, a 4, now holds $658.6M, up from $491.9M.
Inside the Worst Bucket
The biggest is a senior loan of $358.8M, made in June 2022 against apartment properties in several locations. Next come two Texas apartment loans, in Houston and Mesquite, totaling $117.7M. Both were moved in July to a cost-recovery basis, with $5.7M reserved.
Two smaller names round out the group. One is a $35M San Francisco office loan that has not accrued since September 2024. The other is a Maryland hotel loan, $22.5M in Gaithersburg, that stopped accruing in January 2025.
Overall, $896.3M of loans were 90-plus days delinquent, versus $437.1M at year-end.
Foreclosures and Reserves
The REIT took the five apartment properties in Georgia, Colorado and Texas and carries them at $241.3M combined. It charged off $6.9M tied to loans in Austin and Roswell.
The problem isn’t unique to this fund. Our look at apartment reappraisals found CRED iQ data showing values on 295 securitized apartment loans down 33%, with 57% now carrying more debt than the property is worth.
Its loan-loss reserve shrank to $48.5M from $77.3M at year-end. Q3 saw a $27.1M release of general reserves, partly offset by $12.6M of specific reserves, and the REIT credits its macro assumptions for the nine-month drop.
Earnings Halve and Returns Turn Negative
Q3 net income halved to $30.3M from $59.8M, even with a $14.7M credit-loss benefit helping. Net interest income dropped to $45.9M from $66.3M, and MFFO fell to $29.7M from $47.6M.
Every one of the seven share classes posted losses in both September and October, ending a run that management touted as 77 positive months through August. It pointed to markdowns from higher rates and wider assumed exit cap rates. By AltsWire’s math, NAV on Oct. 31 sat 2.1% to 2.2% below June 30 across classes.
The company called September its biggest one-month total-return decline for its I and S share classes, yet it has been positive in 101 of the 105 months since launch. A 30 basis point distribution cut across all share classes took effect with the February payout, and the lower rate has held since.
Why It Matters: Redemptions Climb
The REIT bought back about 4.6M shares in Q3, which covered every request. September’s 2.2M shares ran about twice July’s 1.05M, and October requests were met in full as well.
Through nine months, the REIT repurchased 15M shares for $367.3M, against $376.4M a year earlier. In March, requests reached 2.1% of NAV, so the board allowed repurchases above the plan’s 2% monthly limit to fill them all.
Bigger mortgage REITs face strain as well. Blackstone Mortgage Trust cut its quarterly payout 36% to 30 cents after a $327M Q3 loss, Bisnow reported.
What’s Next
Lending hasn’t stopped. The REIT funded $609.2M of loans in Q3, versus $54.7M a year earlier, and in October it closed three more, about $284.2M of commitments.
Future Standard sponsors the REIT, and Rialto Capital Management serves as sub-advisor. It opened a new $2.5B continuous offering in June, grew a Capital One facility to $750M and amended two Wells Fargo repurchase facilities in October. Watch how the $358.8M loan resolves and whether repurchase requests keep rising.
