NYC Office Construction Tops 6M SF as Rents Lag Costs

New York has 6.4 million square feet of office space underway, nearly double last year, while most markets can’t justify new towers.
2 min read
NYC Office Construction Tops 6M SF as Rents Lag Costs
  • New York had 6.4 million square feet of office space underway in Q3, nearly twice the prior-year level, per Cushman & Wakefield’s review of North American markets.
  • Manhattan’s $156.64 rent runs almost 60% above the $98.69 it takes to make a new tower pencil, while average rents elsewhere fall about 6% short of that mark.
  • Cushman sees that shortfall lasting into the early 2030s in many markets, which should mean more renovations and build-to-suits and tighter supply of top-tier space.
Key Takeaways

New York is the one big market where office construction is surging. Cushman & Wakefield counted 6.4 million square feet underway in Q3, almost double a year earlier, GlobeSt reports.

Elsewhere the math doesn’t work. Across the North American markets the firm tracks, 2026 rents average $77.03 per square foot, roughly 6% under the level at which a new building turns a profit.

What Economic Rent Means

Cushman’s economic rent is the rent a project needs to cover land, building, operating, leasing and financing costs and still leave the developer a margin.

Market rents fell below that line in 2023, as construction costs leapt and debt got pricier. Cushman doesn’t see the gap closing before the early 2030s.

New York Is the Outlier

Manhattan rent averages $156.64 per square foot, nearly 60% over its $98.69 threshold. New towers have been leasing above both numbers.

Owners are also spending on existing buildings, with renovation work covering over 2.5 million square feet as tenants chase better space.

Other Markets Trail

San Francisco is closest among U.S. peers. Its $98.43 rent trails a $102.94 threshold by 4%, and Cushman expects AI demand to help despite 31.1% Class A vacancy.

Boston sits 8% short with nothing under construction or renovation. Both cities should reach their thresholds in 2029, the firm projects.

Chicago has the largest gap: $84.56 against $93.75, or 10% below, with a fix expected in 2032. Toronto is forecast to catch up near 2031, and Vancouver stays under through 2035.

Zoom Out

The pipeline fits a tight base. Yardi Matrix data we covered in October put Manhattan office vacancy at 10.2% in September, the lowest of the top 25 U.S. markets, with 5.6 million square feet under construction across 11 projects.

Why It Matters

Offices take three to five years to build. Even where rents catch up in 2029, new supply would be slow to follow.

Sandy Romero, who leads office and alternatives insights at Cushman, said tenants are already renewing or starting searches sooner because good space is contested.

What’s Next

Romero expects owners to favor renovations and build-to-suits, with new starts staying picky. In New York, the test is whether today’s rents hold as the 6.4 million square feet delivers.

CRE Daily - No Cap

podcast

No CAP by CRE Daily

No Cap by CRE Daily is a weekly podcast offering an unfiltered look into commercial real estate’s biggest trends and influential figures.

CRE Daily Newsletters

Join 65k+
  • operators
  • developers
  • brokers
  • owners
  • landlords
  • investors
  • lenders

who start their day with CRE Daily.

The latest news and trends in commercial real estate delivered to your inbox. Get smarter about what matters in just 5-minutes or less.