Fannie and Freddie Privatization Stalls on $328B Capital Gap

The push to take Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac private has lost steam as a $328 billion capital shortfall dwarfs a planned $30 billion IPO.
3 min read
Fannie and Freddie Privatization Stalls on $328B Capital Gap
  • The Trump administration’s plan to take Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac private has faded, with Mizuho cutting its odds of a deal by 2028 and both stocks down about 63% to 65% from highs.
  • Experts point to a roughly $328 billion capital shortfall, Treasury’s $192 billion senior preferred stake and mortgage-rate risk as reasons a $30 billion IPO could not work.
  • With privatization shelved, attention turns to FHFA Director Bill Pulte’s policies and to multifamily lending, where higher rates have slowed agency originations and pushed some borrowers to private-label CMBS.
Key Takeaways

The push to take Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac private has lost momentum, according to Commercial Observer, which spoke with former agency officials and housing finance experts.

Mizuho cut its odds of privatization by 2028 by about 12 percentage points from 30% for Fannie and 20% for Freddie, Barron’s reported. Fannie’s stock sat near $4.43 on Nov. 11, down 63% from its 52-week high, and Freddie’s near $3.98, off nearly 65%.

From “Stay Tuned” to Silence

President Donald Trump supported privatization in a May 2025 post. He wrote that the time seemed right. Then, in July 2025, the administration summoned the CEOs of the six largest banks. Officials discussed selling up to $30 billion in preferred shares.

Today, even supporters call the plan ambitious. Jeffrey Ketron of Northmarq said untangling the companies from conservatorship could take years. Meanwhile, former Freddie Mac official Clifford Rossi sees the idea shelved for the foreseeable future. He also expects a new Congress to scrutinize FHFA.

The Capital Math

The two agencies hold an estimated $7.5 trillion in loans. Together, they underpin roughly 70% of the U.S. housing market. Fannie Mae needs about $187 billion in capital, while Freddie Mac needs roughly $141 billion.

However, Treasury’s $192 billion senior preferred position does not count toward regulatory capital. Former Freddie Mac CEO Donald Layton calls the resulting shortfall of about $328 billion a trap. A $30 billion offering cannot close that gap. In July, he also warned that investors would view the structure as a poison pill.

Additionally, Rossi warned that removing the implicit federal backstop could push mortgage rates higher. That would be difficult to sell during an affordability push.

Pulte’s Playbook

FHFA Director Bill Pulte now serves as chairman of both companies. During his 20-month tenure, their combined portfolio of loans and securities ballooned from $40 billion to $225 billion. The move aims to lower mortgage rates.

However, Rossi said the buildup reverses post-2008 guardrails. He also criticized the “lender choice” credit score policy. In his view, the agencies take on risk without receiving compensation for it.

What It Means for Multifamily

FHFA set 2026 multifamily purchase caps at $88 billion for each agency, a 20.5% increase. Since then, the 10-year Treasury has reached 20-year highs, while mortgage rates have topped 7%.

Meanwhile, Michael Fratantoni of the Mortgage Bankers Association said sponsors paused in the third quarter. This followed a 70% year-over-year jump in bank CRE lending during the second quarter. Agency delinquency rates have also climbed to nearly 70 basis points. In addition, agency origination growth of 7.1% trails the 20% increase across all multifamily capital sources.

As a result, some owners are turning to private-label CMBS. Ariel Property Advisors’ Shimon Shkury also said new agency underwriting assumes no rent growth for five to seven years on New York rent-stabilized buildings.

Why It Matters

The market has shifted away from the exit story. We previously reported that Ackman expected an exit after the midterms. However, stock prices and Mizuho’s revised odds now suggest otherwise.

For borrowers, the agencies remain the dominant source of multifamily debt. Therefore, incremental policy changes appear more likely than a structural overhaul.

What’s Next

Sam Chandan of NYU Stern expects small administrative tweaks rather than a full exit. He said a later Congress and administration will likely handle any broader privatization effort.

CRE Daily - No Cap

podcast

No CAP by CRE Daily

No Cap by CRE Daily is a weekly podcast offering an unfiltered look into commercial real estate’s biggest trends and influential figures.

CRE Daily Newsletters

Join 65k+
  • operators
  • developers
  • brokers
  • owners
  • landlords
  • investors
  • lenders

who start their day with CRE Daily.

The latest news and trends in commercial real estate delivered to your inbox. Get smarter about what matters in just 5-minutes or less.