- The residential condo board at 75 Wall Street has filed a lawsuit alleging the Hyatt Centric Wall Street Hotel owes nearly $490K in unpaid common and utility charges.
- Owner Navika Capital’s failure to pay has reportedly left the condo board struggling to meet its own financial obligations, prompting threats of service suspensions from vendors.
- Additional legal troubles are mounting for Navika’s Naveen Shah, who is also facing a $2.4M lawsuit from New York hotel labor groups over unpaid benefit fund contributions.
Tensions are rising at 75 Wall Street, where residents say their new hotel neighbors have put the entire building’s finances in jeopardy, reports The Real Deal. The residential condo board has filed a lawsuit against the owner of the Hyatt Centric Wall Street Hotel, alleging nearly $490K in unpaid fees.
A Growing Rift
According to the lawsuit, the building’s master board—comprised of both residential and commercial representatives—has failed to take action against the hotel, despite mounting unpaid charges. The board claims this inaction has forced the condo association into financial distress, making it difficult to pay for services, insurance, and utilities.
The Details
Naveen Shah’s Navika Capital bought the hotel for $85M in 2021. Since then, the hotel has allegedly fallen behind on common and utility charges, ceasing payments on utilities as recently as January 2023 and missing special assessments since April 2024. Attempts to settle the dispute, including a proposed $1M special assessment and a special meeting in June 2024, were unsuccessful. The master board even rejected recommendations to pursue a lien or foreclosure.
Get Smarter about what matters in CRE
Stay ahead of trends in commercial real estate with CRE Daily – the free newsletter delivering everything you need to start your day in just 5-minutes
Financial Pressures Mount
Emails from the building’s managing agent show that vendors have increasingly threatened to suspend services due to unpaid invoices. Meanwhile, Shah, responding to concerns over past due balances, claimed the hotel had already overpaid, further escalating tensions.
Additional Legal Woes
Shah and Navika Capital are also facing another lawsuit filed in May 2024 by New York hotel labor groups, accusing the hotel ownership of failing to contribute over $2.4M to health and pension benefit funds, even after an arbitration award mandated payment.
Why It Matters
The situation highlights the fragile relationship between residential condo owners and commercial entities sharing mixed-use buildings. When one party fails to meet obligations, the financial health of the entire property can be jeopardized, leading to legal battles and operational instability.
What’s Next
Unless a settlement is reached or the hotel clears its debts, the condo board could escalate legal action, possibly reviving foreclosure efforts previously rejected by the master board. Broader financial fallout for the building remains a risk if payments continue to lag.
