- Summit Properties’ $451M bid for Pinnacle’s 5,200-unit New York multifamily portfolio is under review.
- Summit’s local management has links to the brother of Pinnacle CEO Joel Wiener, raising questions about conflicts.
- The city is concerned about Summit’s capacity to repair and stabilize thousands of rent-regulated apartments.
- Pinnacle’s portfolio faces over $12M in arrears and more than 5,000 unresolved housing violations.
Bidder Under the Microscope
Bisnow reports that Summit Properties USA, led by Zohar Levy, has emerged as the lead bidder for Pinnacle Group’s 5,200-unit New York multifamily portfolio. The $451M bid, if successful, would make Summit one of the largest apartment owners in New York City virtually overnight. However, city officials are demanding more information on the bid, Summit’s ownership, and its viability as a long-term operator for thousands of rent-stabilized units.
Complex Ties and Past Performance
Investor materials link Summit’s local property management to Denali Management, headed by Jonathan Wiener—brother to Pinnacle CEO Joel Wiener. While Chestnut Holdings, Jonathan Wiener’s company, denies involvement in the Summit bid, the connection has drawn additional scrutiny. Both Wieners have histories as prominent landlords, with portfolios that have faced legal and regulatory challenges.
Get Smarter about what matters in CRE
Stay ahead of trends in commercial real estate with CRE Daily – the free newsletter delivering everything you need to start your day in just 5-minutes
City’s Concerns Grow
City attorneys and the mayor’s office question Summit’s ability to rehabilitate and manage the troubled multifamily portfolio. New York multifamily assets in the bid have accumulated over $12.7M in arrears and thousands of violations. Officials warn that, without a credible plan, the burden to address these issues may fall to the city or tenants if building conditions worsen further.
Market Pressure and Financial Strain
Pinnacle’s finances have deteriorated since stricter rent laws were enacted in 2019, undermining its longtime acquisition-and-rehab model. Court filings reveal Pinnacle’s parent company faces a $549M capital shortfall and over $1.1B in obligations to lenders and bondholders. Amid these financial strains, questions swirl about whether the regulated rents across the New York multifamily buildings can sustain the bid price—and the necessary repairs. In a broader context, some recent high-profile asset sales have drawn scrutiny for accepting bids significantly below peak offers, raising concerns over how distressed sellers weigh speed and certainty against price.
What’s Next
The bankruptcy auction for the new owner of these New York multifamily assets is set for Thursday, as the city intensifies its push to prioritize tenant protections and portfolio rehabilitation. Whether Summit can clear regulatory and operational hurdles remains the pivotal issue for the future of these rent-regulated apartments.
