- Chicago posted 4.2% year-over-year rent growth in May, third-highest nationally, with other Midwest cities like Indianapolis and Madison also outpacing the 1% national average.
- Major investors—including Morgan Properties and Clear Investment Group—are deploying hundreds of millions into the Midwest multifamily sector, attracted by strong fundamentals and value.
- A supply-demand imbalance and economic resiliency are fueling interest, even as macro headwinds like high construction costs and interest rates persist.
Long seen as a value play compared to the coasts, the Midwest multifamily market is enjoying a long-awaited spotlight, reports Bisnow. Driven by strong rent growth, limited new supply, and renewed investor focus, cities like Chicago, Indianapolis, and Madison are drawing serious capital from national and local players alike.
Rent Heatwave
Chicago saw 4.2% year-over-year rent growth in May—trailing only Brookline, Massachusetts, and Hollywood, Florida—according to CoStar. Other Midwest cities followed suit, with Indianapolis and Madison followed suit, with 2.6% and 2.3% growth respectively, signaling a robust regional trend far outpacing the national average of 1%.
Get Smarter about what matters in CRE
Stay ahead of trends in commercial real estate with CRE Daily – the free newsletter delivering everything you need to start your day in just 5-minutes
Investor Momentum
Morgan Properties announced a $500M multifamily push into the Midwest in April, while Chicago-based Clear Investment Group (CIG) launched a $300M workforce housing fund in March. With Sun Belt markets showing signs of overbuilding, investors see a window of opportunity in central US cities offering job growth, demographic stability, and higher yields.
Capitalizing On Distress
Acquisition activity is rising as investors target strong assets with capital stacks that no longer work under current interest rates. Chicago multifamily sales doubled year-over-year in Q1 2025, with Class-A units seeing a 33% price spike from the recent average.
Limited New Supply
Despite investor appetite, new construction in the Midwest remains constrained. Only 1,200 Class-A units are expected to deliver in Chicago over the next three years, according to Luxury Living. Developers like Focus just opened the second phase of its Fox Valley Mall redevelopment. They say deals can still make sense—with the right underwriting.
Headwinds Remain
Construction costs, elevated interest rates, and labor shortages—exacerbated by immigration policy shifts—are still throttling new development. But with strong rental demand and the growing gap between renting and owning, multifamily remains a favored hedge against inflation.
Workforce Opportunity
CIG is focusing on stabilizing underperforming workforce housing assets, a niche less crowded by institutional players. The firm sees long-term potential in repositioning these properties amid ongoing demand for affordable rentals.
Why It Matters
After years in the shadow of gateway and Sun Belt cities, the Midwest is reasserting itself as a stable, high-performing multifamily market. As demographic trends normalize post-Covid and investor priorities shift toward value and stability, the region’s multifamily sector is positioned for durable growth.
What’s Next
Limited new supply and rising investment could drive continued rent growth and property value increases in Midwest cities through 2026. Investors hunting for margin in today’s tough climate may finally shed the region’s long-held “poor stepchild” label for good.
